This book comes to you from the Centre for Education and Documentation (CED), DOC-CENTRE to most of you. As documentalists and as an organisation in the voluntary sector concerned with development and justice issues, we share and disseminate development information.
This is done in various ways. You can come to CED and refer to the file that consists of clippings from newspapers and grey literature, that have been meticulously culled out for over last twenty years, or you can access the catalogue of reports, books, videos and journal articles.
For those who cannot come to CED, we have various systems of DOCPOST, whereby you select the topic and the time frame, and get the documentation by post. The information, therefore, is tailored to your individual needs.
We also have DOCALERT, a monthly subject-wise listing of important books, reports and clippings sent to you by email. Select what you want and we’ll sent it to you. You can also check our catalogue, which is posted on our website www.doccentre.org.
In yet another effort to reach out to NGOs and People’s Organisations and to enable readers who would like to have ready references of books and articles on important topics that concern us, we have brought out three backgrounders. This one of the Women’s Movement, and another one on Globalisation and the third on Globalisation. The form used in each of these books is different. Further backgrounders, if any, will depend on the feedback we receive from you.
We outline the background to the issues in simple, but not simplistic terms. We do not attempt to be the final word, to force an opinion or to present an exhaustive treatise on the subject; rather just to begin the exploration. We also point out to available readings and references on each of the sub-topics. Each of these references are available at CED. We hope that this will help you read further. To enable you to locate the references at CED we have indicated our reference code for each document or article in square brackets[ eg.{R.A71c.600].
We are grateful to SWISSAID for funding this project.
This backgrounder, ‘Changing the Stream’ presents an overview of issues
relating to women and gender that have been articulated and highlighted
by over three decades of the women’s movement in India.
The term “Women’s Movement” does not indicate any one, unified, linear
entity. The movement is constituted by the energies and activism of several
movements working on a range of issues, using different approaches at various
points of time. It is a term used for convenience and in recognition of
the idea that we are all working, in one way or another, towards the emancipation
of women.
This document attempts to indicate where-we-are-now in the movement and to capture the myriad strands present today, with a brief look at their beginnings. Women’s issues are purportedly high on the agenda of voluntary action - be it grassroots social action groups, NGOs or funding NGOs. The nature of this engagement will be taken up in the sequel to this backgrounder.
The aim of these backgrounders is to sketch the issues involved, and invite each reader to delve further into issues and themes that interest her/him.
Putting this book together has given us many sleepless nights. We had to ask ourselves, “What do we include?” or the more problematic question- “What do we leave out?” This was especially difficult as we believe, that there is no issue that is not a women’s issue, and that the women’s movement has impacted on all aspects of our lives. There was also a problem of connecting the various issues. There are many ways to thread these concerns together, each equally valid – deciding on one pattern over another provoked much discussion and debate.
All in all, it has been a great experience. Reading about the countless
battles waged by women, individually and collectively, filled us with a
deep sense of awe. As documentalists, what was also exciting was stumbling
upon various little nuggets in the most unlikely places. These are tucked
away in many, many newsletters, pamphlets, flyers, and booklets. We have
pointed to some of these in the text, but we’d like to invite you
to visit CED, to experience this kind of amazement for yourself.
Preface ix
Introduction xi
I. Contextualising the Struggle 1
Defining Through Struggle 2 Facing Resistance
and Denial 5
Reclaiming History 6
II. Our Movement, Ourselves 10
Ideological Positions Within the Movement 10
The Left and Feminism 16
Postmodernism and Feminism
Differing Perceptions 18
The Diversity Within 19
Constituents Of the Women’s Movement 22
Women’s Studies 25
Beijing Conference 29
III. Tracing the Path of the Struggle 33
The Road To Independence 34
Post Independence 36
Coming Into Its Own 38
Landmarks 40
Exploring the Issues In the Struggle 43
IV. Violence Against Women, Women Against Violence 45
Rape 49
Dowry 50
Home Truths : Domestic Violence 51
Prostitution and the Women’s Movement 52
Missing Girls : Sex Pre-Selection 55
What We Do To Our Girls? 56
Sexual Harassment at Work 58
V. The Wrong Arm of the Law? 61
Women and Legal Reform 61
Women’s Rights as Human Rights
Women in Prisons
Various Laws Affecting Women
VI. The Body Politics : Women’s Health 75
Contraceptives and Reproductive Choice 77
VII. Other Engagements 81
The Anti-Arrack Movement 81
Joint Forest Management 86
A Roof of One’s Own : Women and Housing 87
The Media and the Women’s Question 89
VIII. The Politics of Identity 93
Women and Nationalism 93
Culture and Religion 95
Uniform Civil Code 96
Sati 97
Multiple Identities 100
Mandal and Women 102
Women and Sexuality 103
IX. Women and the State 107
Towards a Feminist Theory of the Post Colonial State 107
Women and the Democratic State 110
The Political Woman
Women and the Nuclear State 112
X. Women, Development and the State 115
Women and Work/Women’s Work 120
Women and the Labour Movement 121
Women in the Informal Sector 123
Just Add Women and Stir? Five Year Plans and Women 124
Income Generation and Micro-Credit Schemes 129
Sapping Women: The Structural Adjustment Programme 134
X. Women and Environment 138
XI. The Future : Looking Forward 144
Indentifying Challenges 145
The Challenge of Fundamentalism 146
The Challenge of Globalisation 148
The Challenge of Cooption 150
Blurring of Lines 151
In Lieu of a Conclusion 152