Article by Ajit Ranade published in the Fin.express on July 5
It's About Disclosure, Not Disqualification Election Commission Implements Supreme Court's Order
Last week, just a few days before the deadline,
the Election Commission (EC) issued an order implementing the judgement
passed by the Supreme Court (SC) on May 2. Through this
order, the EC has modified the format of the nomination papers
filled out by candidates seeking to contest election. Candidates
must now disclose details of criminal background (if any), their assets,
their liabilities to public financial institutions,
and their educational qualification. Failure to do so, or furni Hence
until the law gets modified, the EC 's order will at
least ensure some degree of transparency. It will also mean that
public and widespread dissemination of self-declared criminal background
of any candidate cannot attract libelous litigation.
Concerned citizens groups, apart from rival parties will put
some sunshine on shady pasts, self declared
via affidavits. This can only help, not hinder the democratic
process. It is instructive to note that government rules already
requ If Indian democracy aspires to be on par with the advanced
democracies of the West, we must not resist steps that
enable greater disclosure. After all, as a famous poet once
said, "what is freedom of speech if the tongue is cut off".
Or what is freedom of the press, if there is widespread
illiteracy? In that spirit, what is the meaning of freedom
of choice (of electors) if that choice is
constrained by a complete blackout of information.
Economists take pride in India's growth.
Ajit Ranade
chief economist
abn amro bank, india
tel: +91.22.281.8008
fax:+91.22.281.8252
ajit.ranade@in.abnamro.com
___________________________________________________________________________________________